Consequences and Repercussions

Even though we spend a lot of time studying, discussing, and dissecting learning theory and various training methods, the fact of the matter is, training dogs really isn't rocket science. It would be ludicrous to suggest that any one, specific training method is the only way or even the right way to train in terms of getting a dog to perform a certain behavior. However it would be equally ludicrous to suggest that the methods we use and manner in which we get a dog to perform a behavior is not going to have consequences and repercussions, not only to the dog, but to the relationship we have with him. I've always considered it my good fortune to have experienced the progression of dog training and to have utilized many different methods and tools. I started out training for competition during the widely accepted, compulsion exclusive, Koehler method days. Back then (and still today), it was all about getting the best, most crisp performance and reliability from your dog. Let me tell you, it worked. Still does. Today we have many alternate methods and less aversive tools available, and you know what, these tools and techniques work too. Choices are good. We all have to make that choice for ourselves. For me I base my choice on three factors, 1) which method and tools will have the least negative impact on the relationship I have with my dog, 2) does the means justify the end, and 3) how will I feel about myself after utilizing the particular tools/method?

I like to watch my dogs thinking and making choices. When they choose correctly, I (and I believe they) really feel triumphant! However I do teach that there are certain non-negotiable behaviors that a dog simply must comply with for safety reasons. "Leave It" is one of those. Although I teach the behavior using positive reinforcement, once the behavior is learned and practical application arises, I leave little room for choice. I deliver that cue much more sternly than most others. And should my dog ignore the cue and continue to try to get something potentially harmful to him, he will be stopped in his tracks by any means necessary. It could save his life. In this case, the means unarguably justifies the end. To get a perfect 200 in the obedience ring, not so much.

I can state unequivocally that the relationships I have with my dogs today are far deeper, more consistent, and much more mutually pleasurable than the relationships I had with my dogs back then. This is not only attributed to the training methods and tools I use, but moreso to the choices I've made in how I want to live my life with them, how I want them to view me, and at the end of the day, my desire to be able to look at myself in the mirror without wincing.